NYX Gel Eyeliner & Smudger is, I believe, a fairly new release. I purchased the shade Cobalt Blue (also known as Samantha, I have no idea why). There’s also a really lovely looking teal (known as Danielle) as well as your more standard black, brown, and dark brown.
I’ve only tested this out as an eyeliner. There was no smudging or smearing, but it faded some by the end of the day. The arm swatch stained my skin, but I didn’t notice any staining on my eyelids.
*I purchased this product. This post contains affiliate links. Please see my disclosure policy for more information.