NYC City Proof Twistable Intense Lip Color Crayons Swatches & Review

Purchased – No Affiliate Links
NYC lip crayons

NYC Ballroom Blush & Riverside Rose City Proof Twistable Intense Lip Colors

NYC has released a few new products for 2014, including the Expert Last Lipsticks which I reviewed a little over a week ago. I had intended to post this review of the new lip crayons the next day, but somehow it fell off my radar.  So, today I have swatches and a review of two of the shades of the lip crayons, which are called the City Proof Twistable Intense Lip Colors (quite a long name).

The lip crayons come in twelve colors and retail for $3.99 each.  They are housed in a plastic casing with a clear lid that looks and feels a bit cheap, but that’s okay with me given the price. They are fairly slippery feeling – more like the Hard Candy All Glossed Up pencils and Wet n Wild Megaslicks Balm Stains than the Revlon Balm Stains or Jordana Balm Stains. They’re less sheer than the NYC Sweet Splash Gloss Sticks from last summer – these are quite opaque.  Unfortunately, they have a fairly strong sweet-chemical smell that I find quite offputting, though it does fade quickly.

NYC Ballroom Blush Riverside Rose swatches

Ballroom Blush // Riverside Rose

The good news is that both colors are really lovely and the product looks, I think, very nice when applied – the texture doesn’t feel great to me (though it’s acceptable), but it does look nice!

NYC Ballroom Blush lip crayon swatch

Ballroom Blush

Ballroom Blush is an opaque bright pink. I don’t have any similar lip crayons, but I don’t buy pinks very often.

NYC Riverside Rose lip crayon swatch

Riverside Rose

Riverside Rose is a rosy neutral. It’s quite close in color to Wet n Wild Rico Mauve (swatched), but since the Wet n Wild has no scent, I prefer that.

There has certainly been an explosion of chubby pencils / lip crayons lately at the drugstore – probably due to the success of the Revlon balm stains (which I bet were influenced by the Clinique Chubby Sticks & Tarte LipSurgence pencils).  Are you a fan of the lip crayon trend, or do you prefer traditional lipsticks?

  • Hey Emi, I am more of a fan of traditional lipsticks, but Ballroom Pink looks REALLY good! Riverside Rose is an adorable shade as well, but the brighter ones always have me at hello 🙂

  • Xero

    I bought the more brown-toned shade and I actually really love the formula. I thought it was really expensive for NYC (and for such a small amount of product) but I fell in love with it! I’m trying to ease myself into a no-buy so I can’t justify getting more of these but I totally want more of them!

  • I love lip crayons because they’re so easy to apply and there’s always something fun about literally drawing on your face.